Israeli officials objected Thursday to U.S. President Joe Biden’s decision to pause a shipment of some weapons to Israel amid concern over Israel’s plan to expand a military operation in Rafah that the United States does not support.
Israeli Ambassador to the United Nations Gilad Erdan called the move “a difficult and very disappointing statement to hear from a president to whom we have been grateful since the beginning of the war.”
Far-right Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir posted on X, formerly known as Twittter, “Hamas loves Biden.”
Biden told CNN in an interview aired Wednesday night that the U.S. would continue to supply Israel with defensive arms, such as Iron Dome munitions.
“I made it clear that if they go into Rafah — they haven’t gone in Rafah yet — if they go into Rafah, I’m not supplying the weapons that have been used historically to deal with Rafah, to deal with the cities, that deal with that problem,” he said.
Biden’s decision followed discussions with Israel on how it will “operate differently against Hamas there than they have elsewhere in Gaza,” a senior administration official said in a statement sent to VOA. The official spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss the sensitive matter.
A ground assault on Rafah, in the southern part of Gaza, would endanger the lives of 1.3 million civilians who evacuated from the north and central parts of the territory to seek safety from Israel’s military response to Hamas’ October 7 attack on Israel.
Administration officials have repeatedly said the U.S. will not support a Rafah invasion unless Israel provides a credible plan on how it would protect civilians. In an April 4 phone call, Biden warned Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu he would withhold military aid unless Israel changes its war conduct.
Deliberations on withholding arms began in April as Israel seemed closer to a decision on Rafah, the official said. Since then, the Israelis “have not fully addressed our concerns,” and the decision to pause the arms transfer was executed “last week.”
The shipment was supposed to consist of 1,800 907-kilogram (2,000 pound) bombs and 1,700 226-kilogram (500 pound) bombs. The administration said it is mainly concerned with the “end-use of the 2,000-lb. bombs and the impact they could have in dense urban settings as we have seen in other parts of Gaza.”
The official said other equipment under review includes Joint Direct Attack Munition kits that convert so-called dumb bombs into precision-guided munitions.
The paused shipments are drawn from previously appropriated funds, not from the supplemental appropriations that Congress passed in April.
“We are committed to ensuring Israel gets every dollar appropriated in the supplemental,” the official said, highlighting the recent approval of $827 million worth of weapons and equipment, the latest tranche of foreign military financing.
The pause marks the first time the U.S. leveraged a weapons transfer to influence Israel’s war conduct since Hamas’ October 7 terror attack.
Former President Donald Trump accused Biden in a social media post early Thursday of "taking the side” of Hamas.
Members of the U.S. House of Representatives from Biden’s Democratic Party praised the move, including Representative Ayanna Pressley, who said the United States “has a clear obligation to stop the massacre of innocent civilians.”
Democratic Representative Seth Moulton said he was even more skeptical of Israel’s plan for Rafah after meeting with the Israeli ambassador.
“I've always said that Israel must defeat Hamas. The question is whether invading Rafah ultimately helps or hurts that cause,” Moulton said. “I support President Biden’s decision.”
Lawmakers push back
In a Senate hearing Wednesday, U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin told lawmakers that the administration had not made a final determination on how to proceed with the shipment, “in the context of the unfolding events in Rafah.”
The announcement was welcomed by progressive Democrats but criticized by Republican lawmakers.
Democratic Senator Peter Welch praised the Biden administration for pausing deliveries of “bombs that have devastated Gaza.”
But Senate Republicans called Biden’s decision a serious deportation from normal procedures.
“The non-partisan weapons sales process has kept the domestic political squabbles out of this for a long, long time. It's been in place for about a half a century and it has worked really, really well. The administration has stepped outside those boundaries,” Senator Jim Risch, the top Republican on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, told reporters Thursday.
“The administration allowed these weapons sales. Myself and the other three members of Congress closely looked at these sales and take that obligation seriously, all signed off on it. And now in the heat of battle this administration is saying we're going to pull this back. This is unprecedented.”
McConnell and Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson sent Biden a letter demanding answers from the Biden administration on why the administration had delayed the arms delivery.
Reports of the pause in the weapons shipment first surfaced Tuesday on the same day that President Biden reiterated his support for Israel.
“My commitment to the safety of the Jewish people, the security of Israel, and its right to exist as an independent Jewish state is ironclad, even when we disagree,” he said in an impassioned speech Tuesday to honor the memory of the six million Jews killed during the Holocaust and other victims of Nazi persecution.
Israel is the largest recipient of U.S. aid, nearly $4 billion a year, most of it in the form of military assistance.
“The American taxpayer has subsidized Israel's manufactured humanitarian crisis in Gaza,” said Ari Tolany, director of security assistance, arms trade and technology at the Center for International Policy. “If the administration will continue to arm and train Israel no matter what, Israel has no incentive to change its behavior,” she told VOA.
The decision follows a whirlwind of events in the past few days regarding the possibility of a cease-fire in Gaza.
A deal to end hostilities paired with the release of hostages held by Hamas for Palestinians detained in Israeli jails appeared within reach Monday when Hamas said it has accepted the terms for truce. Netanyahu rejected that version of the deal and ordered Israeli forces to carry out a “limited operation” in eastern Rafah.
Report to Congress
At the same time, the administration missed a Wednesday deadline to submit a report to Congress on whether Israel is violating humanitarian law while using U.S.-supplied weapons in Israel’s war against Hamas.
State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller said during Tuesday’s briefing that the National Security Memorandum "will not be transmitted today. We continue to work to finalize the report. We expect to deliver it in the very near future.”
Under the National Security Memorandum 20 (NSM20), issued in February, Biden directed the departments of State and Defense to report to Congress within 90 days on whether U.S. partners that were provided with American weapons have complied with international and U.S. laws.
That includes the Leahy Laws, two legislative provisions named for Senator Patrick Leahy, that mandate the U.S. cut off assistance to any foreign military or law enforcement units if it determines there is credible evidence of human rights violations.
Israel provided its assurances of NSM20 compliance in March, and the State Department was due to report to Congress on Wednesday whether it finds Israel's assurances credible.
The delay could be due to a “substantive disagreement being resolved or just regular bureaucracy,” rather than an effort to created added pressure on Israel, said Josh Paul, former director of the State Department agency that deals with weapons transfers.
“But we will see what the report says,” Paul told VOA. “If it becomes an extended delay, that could be indicative of a rewrite.”
Human rights groups and independent observers have for weeks called for a suspension of American weapons transfers to Israel, alleging they have been used in violation of international humanitarian and human rights law.
In April, Paul, alongside other former administration officials and academicians, submitted a report detailing what it said were unlawful Israeli attacks on civilians using American weapons.
Amnesty International submitted a similar report ahead of the NSM20 deadline.
VOA congressional correspondent Katherine Gypson and Pentagon correspondent Carla Babb and State Department bureau chief Nike Ching contributed to this report.
