A U.S. trade commission on Friday handed an unexpected victory to Bombardier Inc. against Boeing Co., in a ruling that allows the Canadian company to sell its newest jets to U.S. airlines without heavy duties, sending Bombardier's shares up 15 percent.
The U.S. International Trade Commission's unanimous decision was the latest twist in U.S.-Canadian trade relations that have been complicated by disputes over tariffs on Canadian lumber and U.S. milk and President Donald Trump's desire to renegotiate or even abandon the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).
Trump, who did not weigh in on the dispute personally, took his "America First" message to the world's elite on Friday, telling a summit that the United States would "no longer turn a blind eye" to what he described as unfair trade practices.
The ITC commissioners voted 4-0 that Bombardier's prices did not harm Boeing and discarded a U.S. Commerce Department recommendation to slap a near 300 percent duty on sales of the company's 110- to 130-seat CSeries jets for five years. It did not give a reason immediately.
U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross said in a statement that the commission's finding "shows how robust our system of checks
and balances is."
Boeing's shares closed flat.
"It's reassuring to see that facts and evidence matter," said Chad Bown, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington. "This part of the trade policy process works unimpeded despite President Trump's protectionist rhetoric."
Removing 'uncertainty'
The decision will also help Bombardier sell the CSeries in the United States by removing "a huge amount of uncertainty," at a time when its Brazilian rival Embraer is bringing its new E190-E2 jet to market, a source familiar with the
Canadian plane and train maker's thinking said.
The ITC had been expected to side with Chicago-based Boeing. The company alleged it was forced to discount its 737 narrow-bodies to compete with Bombardier, which it said used government subsidies to dump the CSeries during the 2016 sale of 75 jets at "absurdly low" prices to Delta Air Lines.
Bombardier called the trade case self-serving after Boeing revealed on December 21 that it was discussing a "potential combination" with Embraer. Boeing denied the trade case was motivated by those talks.
Boeing to look at options
The dispute may not be over. "This can still be appealed by Boeing," Andrew Leslie, parliamentary secretary to Canadian Foreign Minister Chrystia
Freeland, told reporters in Montreal.
Boeing said it would not consider such options before seeing the ITC's reasoning in February.
But Boeing said it was disappointed the commission did not recognize "the harm that Boeing has suffered from the billions of dollars in illegal government subsidies that the Department of Commerce found Bombardier received and used to dump aircraft in the U.S. small single-aisle airplane market."
Bombardier, Delta and the U.S. consumer advocacy group Travelers United all called the ITC decision a victory for consumers and airlines.
The decision may end up helping Trump's goal of boosting U.S. jobs as the CSeries jets for U.S. airlines will be built in the United States rather than Canada.
Through a venture with European planemaker Airbus SE, which has agreed to take a majority stake in the CSeries this year, Bombardier plans to assemble CSeries jets in Alabama to be sold to U.S. carriers starting in 2019.
Sweet surprise
Airbus Chief Executive Tom Enders promised to push ahead "full throttle" with the Alabama plans. "Nothing is sweeter than a surprise, a surprise victory," he said.
The case had sparked trade tensions between the United States and its allies Canada and the United Kingdom. Ottawa last year scrapped plans to buy 18 Super Hornet fighter jets from Boeing.
The well-paid jobs associated with the CSeries are important both to Ottawa and the British government. Bombardier employs about 4,000 workers in Northern Ireland.
The British prime minister's office said it welcomed the decision, "which is good news" for the British industry, while Canada's innovation minister said the ITC came to the "right decision" on Bombardier.
Former ITC Chairman Dan Pearson praised the decision. "Not a single commissioner was willing to buy Boeing's arguments," he said. "I think 'America First' is a policy of the White House and the Commerce Department. But it's not the policy of an independent agency [like the ITC]."
