Texas began Thursday to roll out what will become a floating barrier on the Rio Grande in the latest escalation of Governor Greg Abbott's multibillion-dollar effort to secure the U.S. border with Mexico.
But even before the huge, orange buoys were unloaded from the four semitrailers that had hauled them to the border city of Eagle Pass, there were concerns about this part of Abbott's unprecedented challenge to federal authority over immigration enforcement. Migrant advocates voiced concerns about drowning risks, and environmentalists questioned the impact on the river.
Setting up the barriers could take as long as two weeks, according to Lieutenant Chris Olivarez, a spokesperson for the Texas Department of Public Safety, which is overseeing the project.
Once installed, the above-river parts of the system and the webbing they're connected with will cover 305 meters (1,000 feet) of the middle of the Rio Grande, with anchors in the riverbed.
Eagle Pass is part of a Border Patrol sector that has seen the second-highest number of migrant crossings this fiscal year with about 270,000 encounters, though that is lower than it was at this time last year.
Title 42
The crossing dynamics shifted in May after the Biden administration stopped implementing Title 42, a pandemic-era public health policy that turned many asylum-seekers back to Mexico. New rules allowed people to seek asylum through a government application and set up appointments at the ports of entry, though the maximum allowed in per day is set at 1,450. The Texas governor's policies target the many who are frustrated with the cap and cross illegally through the river.
Earlier iterations of Abbott's border mission have included busing migrants to liberal states; authorizing the National Guard to make arrests; installing miles of razor wire at popular crossing points on the river; and creating state checkpoints beyond federal stops to inspect incoming commercial traffic.
"We always look to employ whatever strategies will be effective in securing the border," Abbott said in a June 8 news conference to introduce the buoy strategy.
But the state hasn't said what tests or studies have been done to determine the risks posed to people who try to get around the barrier or the environmental impacts.
Increasing danger
Immigrant advocates, including Sister Isabel Turcios, a nun who oversees a migrant shelter in Piedras Negras, Mexico, just across the river from Eagle Pass, have remained vigilant about the effects of the new barrier on migration. Turcios said she met with the Texas Department of Public Safety in the days leading up to the arrival of the buoys and was told the floating barrier would be placed in deep waters to function as a warning to migrants to avoid the area.
Turcios said she was aware that many of the nearly 200 migrants staying in her shelter on any given day are not deterred from crossing illegally despite sharp concertina wire. But that wire causes more danger because it forces migrants to spend additional time in the river.
"That's more and more dangerous each time ... because it has perches, it has whirlpools and because of the organized crime," Turcios said.
At the June news conference, Texas Department of Public Safety Director Steven McCraw addressed the danger that migrants may face when the buoys are deployed: "Anytime they get in that water, it's a risk to the migrants. This is the deterrent from even coming in the water."
Less than a week ago, four people, including an infant, drowned near Eagle Pass as they attempted to cross the river.
The federal International Boundary and Water Commission, whose jurisdiction includes boundary demarcation and oversight of U.S.-Mexico treaties, said it didn't get a heads-up from Texas about the proposed floating barrier.
"We are studying what Texas is publicly proposing to determine whether and how this impacts our mission to carry out treaties between the U.S. and Mexico regarding border delineation, flood control and water distribution, which includes the Rio Grande," Frank Fisher, a spokesperson for the commission, said in a statement.
Business owner sues
On Friday morning, environmental advocates from Eagle Pass and Laredo, another Texas border city about 185 kilometers (115 miles) downriver, held a demonstration by the border that included a prayer for the river ahead of the barrier deployment.
Jessie Fuentes, who owns a canoe-and-kayaking business that takes paddlers onto the Rio Grande, said he's worried about unforeseen consequences. On Friday, he sued to stop Texas from using the buoys. He's seeking a permanent injunction, saying his paddling business is affected by limited access to the river.
"I know it's a detriment to the river flow, to the ecology of the river, to the fauna and flora. Every aspect of nature is being affected when you put something that doesn't belong in the river," Fuentes said.
Adriana Martinez, a professor at Southern Illinois University who grew up in Eagle Pass, studies the shapes of rivers and how they move sediment and create landforms. She said she's worried about what the webbing might do.
"A lot of things float down the river, even when it's not flooding - things that you can't see, like large branches, large rocks," Martinez said. "And so anything like that could get caught up in these buoys and change the way that water is flowing around them."
