Accessibility links

Breaking News

El Salvador violated woman's rights in high-risk pregnancy case, court rules


FILE - The Inter-American Court of Human Rights hears a case involving a woman who in 2013 was forced to carry a high-risk pregnancy to term, in San Jose, Costa Rica, March 22, 2023. The court ruled Dec. 20, 2024, that El Salvador violated her rights.
FILE - The Inter-American Court of Human Rights hears a case involving a woman who in 2013 was forced to carry a high-risk pregnancy to term, in San Jose, Costa Rica, March 22, 2023. The court ruled Dec. 20, 2024, that El Salvador violated her rights.

El Salvador violated a woman's rights after denying her an abortion in 2013 despite doctors' calls to terminate her high-risk pregnancy, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) said Friday.

The case of the woman, a domestic worker known as Beatriz, became a symbol of El Salvador's blanket ban on abortion, which punishes with prison time those who undergo the procedure, perform it or assist with it.

The court's decision found the Salvadoran state "internationally responsible for failing to fulfill its duty of due diligence in ensuring the rights to access effective judicial remedies, personal integrity, health and privacy" for Beatriz.

Doctors diagnosed Beatriz, then 22 and suffering from lupus and other ailments, with her second high-risk pregnancy in February 2013 and said the fetus would not survive the pregnancy. They recommended an abortion but would not perform the procedure given El Salvador's severe prohibition.

Beatriz appealed to the Supreme Court, which rejected her request. In June 2013, she underwent a cesarean section, and her daughter died hours later.

Beatriz died in 2017 from complications due to a motorcycle accident that occurred en route to a medical appointment.

The IACHR said there was not a proven causal link between Beatriz's death in 2017 and the medical care during her second pregnancy in 2013, so it did not rule on state responsibility for her death.

In its ruling, the IACHR ordered El Salvador to implement measures such as creating guidelines and protocols for medical and judicial personnel to ensure legal clarity and proper care in similar cases.

"The lack of legal certainty regarding the handling of Beatriz's case led to the bureaucratization and judicialization of the necessary medical care, resulting in multiple consequences," the IACHR's statement said.

The El Salvador president's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

At a press conference on Friday, Beatriz's mother, known publicly only as Delmy, celebrated the ruling alongside Beatriz's brother and women's rights activists.

"I know it has not been easy, but the state has the duty and the right to respond to the measures that the court has imposed, and for me, it is a great triumph," she said.

  • 16x9 Image

    Reuters

    Reuters is a news agency founded in 1851 and owned by the Thomson Reuters Corporation based in Toronto, Canada. One of the world's largest wire services, it provides financial news as well as international coverage in over 16 languages to more than 1000 newspapers and 750 broadcasters around the globe.

XS
SM
MD
LG