Accessibility links

Breaking News

Student Union

'Creative Destruction' Pushes Dreams of College Away

'Creative Destruction'
'Creative Destruction'

Where Americans suffer widespread job loss, fewer people go to college.

So says a recent study from Duke University that linked local job loss with lower college attendance rates, worse mental health among adolescents, and increased inequality overall.

When traditional industries make way for more efficient, more technologically advanced industries, a process called “creative destruction”, economists have traditionally thought that young people would shift their education goals, the study said.

Think switching from horses-drawn carriages to cars.

Young people will “shift and ... invest further in education because they’re going to see the path to stable, middle-class lifestyle is now in white-collar work,” said Elizabeth Ananat, one of the study’s authors.

But Ananat, an associate professor of public policy studies and economics at Duke University, called this traditional theory of everyone shifting into the new industries an “optimistic notion.”

“The big takeaway from our study is that these job losses increase inequality in education because the high-income kids are going to go no matter what,” she said.

“It’s the low-income kids who are most strongly affected by these job losses.”

Job loss trickles down emotionally, as well. The Duke study found that beyond not being able to afford tuition, job loss can cause mental and emotional stress among youth. Likewise, it can cause poor academic performance, which sets education downward.

The 2017 Global Youth Wellbeing Index, a survey of approximately 70 percent of the world’s youth across 30 different countries, reported similar conclusions. It found, despite education being the category that consistently ranks highest in well-being, too few young people are getting the preparation they need to be successful in work and life.

The index also found that youth lack adequate mental healthcare. Half of young people feel their lives are too stressful and more than half said the way they feel gets in the way of jobs, school, and life.

“Support for mental health for youth and adults, we think, is critical because one of the strongest sets of findings is that, when there are job losses in communities, it is extremely distressing for people that live there, and not just those who have lost jobs,” said Ananat.

“Traditionally, when policymakers have worries about these kind of large job losses, they’ve mostly worried about how to address the needs of the workers who lost jobs themselves,” said Anna Gassman-Pines, another author.

And while workers need intervention and assistance, the impact is much broader.

"One way of thinking about it could be more of a place-based rather than person-based strategy,” said Gassman-Pines.

The authors explained that person-based strategies often measure the person who lost their job, and look at retraining or extended unemployment and health insurance benefits. But a place-based strategy would be more holistic, treating the job loss as a problem affecting the wider place rather than people.

Ananat and Gassman-Pines say schools should shoulder more weight in helping their students.

“I think a lot of university health services tend to assume that families are a source of support for students who are having struggles,” said Ananat.

“For youth, the education itself is probably the best protection we have for weathering any changes in the economy. It’s not a guarantee, but it’s one of the best forms of insurance we have so it’s a matter of how do we support the students so that they stay in and get through.”

Have you felt stress at school because of what's happening at home? Please share your suggestion in the Comments here, and visit us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and LinkedIn, thanks!

See all News Updates of the Day

‘College Deserts’ leave many communities without higher education options 

FILE - The Cuyahoga Community College campus is shown, May 28, 2019, in Cleveland, OHIO.
FILE - The Cuyahoga Community College campus is shown, May 28, 2019, in Cleveland, OHIO.

“College Deserts” – areas where high schools are located more than 30 miles away from the nearest community college – leave large groups of people unable to pursue higher education because of transportation problems, Lexi Lonas Cochran writes in The Hill.

Most college deserts are in the Southern U.S., with a recent study in Texas showing that long commuting distances discourage many potential students from attending college. (December 2024)

Analysts say rate of college closures likely to increase 

FILE - The Manor House at Goddard College in Plainfield, Vt., is seen on Wednesday, April 10, 2024. The college's Board of Trustees announced Tuesday, April 9, that the school is closing at the end of the semester after years of declining enrollment and financial struggles.
FILE - The Manor House at Goddard College in Plainfield, Vt., is seen on Wednesday, April 10, 2024. The college's Board of Trustees announced Tuesday, April 9, that the school is closing at the end of the semester after years of declining enrollment and financial struggles.

If current trends continue, the rate of college closures is expected to increase, according to a new study reported in Forbes.

Closures are more likely to affect private institutions, and while the number of closures might seem small on a national level, it could cause serious problems for the smaller and mid-sized communities where those colleges are located. (December 2024)

Judge upholds racial considerations in US Naval Academy admissions 

FILE - U.S. Naval Academy midshipmen participate in a formal parade on the school's campus in 2010. (U.S. Navy photo)
FILE - U.S. Naval Academy midshipmen participate in a formal parade on the school's campus in 2010. (U.S. Navy photo)

Although the U.S. Supreme Court last year decided that civilian colleges and universities could not consider race or ethnicity in admissions, a judge ruled that the U.S. Naval Academy had established a national security interest in a diverse officer corps.

That means the academy – and other military service academies – can continue to consider race. A similar policy at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point has also been challenged, but that case has not yet gone to trial, according to a report in Navy Times. (December 2024)

Harvard recommends gap year as a strategic move 

FILE - In this July 16, 2019, file photo people walk past an entrance to Widener Library, behind, on the campus of Harvard University, in Cambridge, Mass.
FILE - In this July 16, 2019, file photo people walk past an entrance to Widener Library, behind, on the campus of Harvard University, in Cambridge, Mass.

While some students and parents see the gap year as a waste of time, others see the break in academic studies as valuable for developing maturity, earning money or focusing goals.

MSN.com explains some of the reasons why Harvard – and other prestigious schools in the United States – are recommending that students take a gap year. (December 2024)

Student dilemma: Financial aid applications can expose undocumented parents

FILE - New graduates line up before the start of the Bergen Community College commencement at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, N.J, May 17, 2018.
FILE - New graduates line up before the start of the Bergen Community College commencement at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, N.J, May 17, 2018.

Many students in the U.S. rely on financial aid to attend colleges and universities, but as Julia Barajas reports in LAist.com, the Free Application for Federal Student Aid could cause a dilemma for students with an undocumented parent.

If students fill out the application, they will share their parents’ financial information – and potentially raise questions about their immigration status -- with the federal government. If they don’t fill out the application, they won’t get federal financial aid. (December 2024)

Load more

XS
SM
MD
LG